‘Bring Back the Orphanages’

There’s a documentary worth watching on Channel 4 tonight at 7.30. ‘Bring Back the Orphanages’ by Phil Frampton is far from misty-eyed, but makes a strong case for residential care:

Frampton chronicled a life of neglect and desolation in that home – along with the best efforts of a well-meaning matron – in his memoir, Golly in the Cupboard. Yet he argues, in a Channel 4 programme to be broadcast on Friday, that the modern emphasis on foster care for nearly 90% of looked-after children is misguided. “This place gave us stability,” he says. “We stayed in the same schools, so our education wasn’t disrupted. It meant we learnt to care for each other, to respect each other, even to love one another. Sibling families were catered for, so that brothers and sisters didn’t have to be split up.”

This splitting of families is barbaric. What could be worse for a child who has been taken into care – particularly after bereavement – than to lose their whole family? When you consider that many children move around a series of temporary homes, separated from brothers and sisters, for the rest of their childhood, it’s hardly surprising that they have what is euphemistically described as ‘poor outcomes’. While a residential home is not right for every child, they should at least have the choice.

As Frampton pointed out in Community Care recently:

Thousands of young people in care are forced to endure 20-plus moves. They lose their friends, their schooling and their self-esteem.

Sibling families, after they are comfortably placed in traditional residential homes, are nowadays also expected to suffer the trauma of being split up. A recent survey carried out by charity A National Voice found that more than 75 per cent of young people in care reported difficulty seeing their siblings.


2 Responses to ‘Bring Back the Orphanages’

  1. hope says:

    also children who have extended families/friends who would willing look after them are refused

    if they manage to keep hold of the children which is no mean feat with all the governments adoption targets to meet

    they are given no support

    yet they continue to pay foster carers just so they have control over the children

  2. archrights says:

    Quite. I hadn’t realised until recently that grandparents/ extended family members who look after children don’t receive any fostering allowance. I was at a meeting where several grandparents who were bringing up their grandchildren described the difficulties of managing with only a state pension to support them all. Appalling.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: